Whilst researching potential new booms I started weighing my existing equipment and comparing it to the published figures. It's probably no surprise that the official numbers are on the optimistic side (to say the least), but I understand less why it's the more modern (and more expensive) equipment that seems to be the heaviest.
Here's a table of kit that I either own now, or used to own, listing its claimed weight vs actual measured weight (I had some old notes to hand to help with this):
| Kit | Year | Claimed Weight | Measured Weight | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tabou Manta 75 | 2005 | 6.5kg | 7.10kg (+9%) | 7.4kg with straps & baseplate |
| North Progression Comp. 150-200 A+ Boom |
2003 | 2.45kg | 2.47kg (+1%) | 2.76kg With lines/Uphaul |
| North Silver 180-230 Boom |
2005 | 2.70kg | 3.12kg inc. | With lines/Uphaul |
| AL360 E3 Carbon Wave/Slalom 160-220 Boom | 2020 | 2.51kg | 2.68kg (+7%) | Incredibly solid but a bit heavy |
| Neil Pryde Supersonic 7.4m | 1999 | 4.12kg | 4.41kg (+5%) | 0.60kg/m2 (0.18mm monofilm) |
| Sailworks Retro 7.5m | 2008 | 4.9kg | 5.40kg (+10%) | 0.72Kg/m2 (pretty bad!) |
| Point-7 AC-X 7.5m (prototype) | 2019 | 4.28kg | 4.60kg (+7%) | 0.62kg/m2 |
| Gaastra Remedy 6.4m | 2006 | 4.2kg | 4.50kg (+7%) | 0.70kg/m2 |
| Sailworks Revolution #9 5.4m | 2003 | 3.8kg | 3.90kg (+3%) | 0.72kg/m2 (damp) |
| Sailworks Revolution SR7 4.6m | 2001 | 3.4kg | 3.50kg (+3%) | 0.76kg/m2 |
| Sailworks Revolution #9 4.2m | 2003 | 3.0kg | 3.10kg (+3%) | 0.74kg/m2 |
| Sailworks Revolution 8 4.0m | 2002 | 2.9kg | 3.10kg (+7%) | 0.77kg/m2 |
| Technofiber Race XL 75% 460 SDM mast | 2003? | 1.90kg | 2.05kg (+8%) | £180 new in 2001. Broke in 2020 |
| Technofiber/DIY Carbon Extender (30cm) | 2020 | n/a | 300g | Home-made from broken mast ^ |
| Technofiber Fusion 55% 460 SDM mast | ?(eBay) | 2.25kg | 2.32kg (+3%) | |
| Point-7 SDM-s K80 80% 460 SDM mast | 2021 | 2.05kg | 1.97kg (-4%) | Lighter than claimed! |
| Tushingham 75% 400 SDM mast | 2005? | 1.6kg | 1.74kg (+9%) | |
| Tushingham 75% 430 mast SDM | 2005? | 1.8kg | 1.91kg (+6%) | |
| North Platinum 100% 400 SDM mast | 2012 | 1.6kg | 1.70kg (+6%) | |
| North Gold 80% 430 SDM mast | 2016 | 1.8kg | 1.94kg (+8%) | |
| Powerex (Chinese version) 60% 370 SDM mast | 2019 | 1.6kg | 1.65kg (+3%) | Well done! |
| North POWER.XT SDM 42 cm (original 1.0 version) | 2000 | ? | 700g | Including downhaul rope. |
| Radz(?) XTS base + Boge joint | 2005? | ? | 350g | |
| Duotone iBASE 2.0 + Boge joint top | 2020 | 310g | 320g (+3%) | At least it's lighter than the Radz. |
| 330ml Can of Coke (minus weight of empty can) | 2020 | 330g | 332g (+0.06%) | So the scales are accurate! |
For sails it makes sense that the weight-per-m2 goes down as sizes get bigger (battens and fittings get less significant), but there are a couple here that stand out:
It's pretty obvious from the table above that some of my oldest kit is also the lightest. It's also obvious that brands are misleading us with their published weights.
Here are some comparisons of old vs new equipment that should be roughly equivalent (and some that aren't!). It should be said that my old kit has lasted extremely well, so I don't think it's a case of things being made more durable and therefore heavier. Brands certainly haven't been getting more honest with their stated weights, either.
| Old Kit | Year | Claimed Weight | vs | New Equivalent / Alternative | Year | Claimed Weight | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Technofiber Race XL 75% 460 | 2001 | 1.90kg | Technofiber Race XL 75% 460 | 2020 | 2.05kg (+150g) | +8% | |
| North POWER.XT SDM 42 cm (original 1.0 version) | 2000 | 690? (actually 700g) | POWER.XT 2.0 SDM 42cm | 2019 | 770g (+80g) (actually 800g) | +12% | |
| Sailworks Retro 6.5m | 1999 | 3.80kg (0.58kg/m2) | Sailworks Retro 6.5m | 2020 | 4.00kg (0.62kg/m2) | +7% | |
| Neil Pryde V8 (2-cam) 8.5m | 1999 | 5.14kg (0.60kg/m2) | Neil Pryde V8 (2-cam) 8.7m | 2020 | 5.45kg (0.63kg/m2) | +5% | |
| Neil Pryde Combat 4.7m (4 battens) | 1999 | 3.05kg (0.65kg/m2) | Neil Pryde Combat 4.7m (4 battens) | 2020 | 3.20kg (0.68kg/m2) | +5% | |
| Sailworks Revolution SR7 4.6m (5 battens) | 2001 | 3.40kg (0.76kg/m2) | Hot Sails Maui KS3 4.6m (3 battens) | 2020 | 2.90kg (0.63kg/m2) | -15% |
The exception here is obviously the one unfair comparison, showing the evolution of the specialist light-weight 3-batten sail - the HSM KS3 showing a significant weight reduction over an old sail. But all the rest… heavier.
If anyone can explain why, please do let me know!
Having just had my Technofiber Race XL mast break, I've done lots more research to find something to replace it with that doesn't weigh more. Not so easy…
These are the Constant Curve mast options that I could find, listed from least desirable to best choice (completely personal opinion of course):
| Mast | Year | Claimed Weight | Diff | Actual Weight | Price | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Technofiber Race XL 75% 460 SDM | 2003? | 1.90kg | Weighs 2.05kg (+8%) | £180 new in 2001 | The benchmark | |
| Duotone Platinum 100% 460 SDM | 2020 | 1.90kg (+/-8%) | Equal | Likely 2.05kg | £739 | Equal weight but HOW MUCH?!! |
| Duotone Gold 90% 460 SDM | 2020 | 1.95kg (+/-8%) | +2% | Likely 2.10kg | £499 | Heavier and expensive! |
| Unifiber Enduro EVO SDM C80 460 | 2020 | 2.35kg (+/-?) | +24% | Likely >2.5kg | £345 inc. £10 for bag | Cheap but much heavier |
| Unifiber Enduro EVO SDM C100 460 | 2020 | 1.90kg (+/-?) | Equal | Likely >2.0kg | £509 inc. £10 for bag | Same weight but expensive |
| Point-7 BlackPrime 100% 460 SDM | 2020 | 1.71kg (+/-5%) | -10% | Likely 1.79kg | £579 | Incredibly light! |
| Point-7 BlackCore 80% 460 SDM | 2020 | 1.90kg (+/-5%) | Equal | Likely 1.99kg | £439 | Best price/weight compromise? |
| Point-7 SDM-s K80 80% 460 SDM | 2021 | 2.05kg (+/-3%) | Equal | Weighs 1.97kg | €449 | 2021 update - weight increased |
What's nice here is that there are options for everyone, trading weight vs cost. Only the Duotone masts stand out as appearing bad value for money, although to be fair they might be the best built or the most durable (I've got know way of knowing).
EDIT: I bought the Point-7 SDM-s mast and it actually weighs less than claimed - the only windsurfing kit that I've ever measured that does so!
I also need to replace my ageing 7.4m sails, so here's a comparison with the 2020 sails that Windsurf Magazine Tested:
| Sail | Year | Claimed Weight | Diff | kg/m2 | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Neil Pryde Supersonic 7.4m | 1999 | 4.12kg (actually 4.41kg) | 0.56 | Even today this is very light! | |
| Duotone E_PACE 7.3m | 2020 | 4.70kg | +14% | 0.64 | |
| Ezzy Cheetah 7.5m | 2020 | N/A (2018 is 4.76kg) | +13% | 0.63 | |
| GA Sails Hybrid 7.2m | 2020 | N/A | |||
| Goya Mark Pro 7.2m | 2020 | N/A | |||
| Gun Sails Rapid 7.2m | 2020 | N/A | |||
| Neil Pryde Speedster 7.2m | 2020 | 4.64kg | +12% | 0.64 | |
| Loft Sails Oxygen 7.3m | 2020 | 4.56kg | +11% | 0.63 | |
| Point-7 AC-X 7.5m | 2020 | 4.28kg (actually 4.60kg) | +4% | 0.57 | Pretty good and the obvious winner |
| RRD Fire 7.6m | 2020 | N/A |
So half of the manufacturers don't even think it's important to state the weight. That is pretty hopeless and I won't be buying from those brands. The Point-7 stands out and might actually equal the old NP sail if it's not seriously overweight, so well done to that brand, but the rest are significantly heavier. Again, why?
Interesting here that Point-7 "win" in both the sail and mast comparisons.
EDIT: I bought a Point-7 AC-X and it compares very well weight-wise to my old NP Supersonic. It's a tiny bit heavier (probably just the weight of the one extra batten) but it feels the same and I'm very happy with it. I don't think I would have chosen Point-7 had I not researched all these figures.