I've recently been thinking of replacing my two aluminium booms with a single carbon one, which should be possible because they tend to offer a little bit more range and the extra stiffness should(?) make up for having to use it close to its maximum extension for my largest light-wind sails.
However, this has proved harder than I expected because when you actually start comparing numbers, it's actually rather hard to beat my old North Progression Comp. boom for lightness, and at short extension at least, it's virtually as stiff as the cheaper carbon booms that I've compared.
This resulted in a mammoth fact-hunting session, and as I read several forum posts wishing for a comparison table, I thought I'd share mine.
Just for reference, these are the two booms that I currently have. The North Progression Comp. seems indestructable and the grip is still in good condition despite it being nearly 20 years old and having survied plenty of "shingle incidents". It feels light and stiff (and is) and the clamp is fantastic. The North Silver on the other hand hasn't been used much, but the grip has suffered far more, and it feels pretty heavy.
| Manufacturer/Model | Length | Clamp | Weight | Grip | Price | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| North Progression Comp. A+ (~2003) |
150 - 200 | Custom with rubber insert. Never slips! |
2.45kg | 32mm Durable |
£n/a | Mine seems to be Indestructable! |
| North Silver (~2005) |
180 - 230 | Custom iFRONT 1.0 |
2.70kg | 32mm Soft |
£n/a | Excellent clamp, poor quality grip |
New boom requirements:
This is my shortlist of aluminium booms. There's far too much hype over carbon booms (even if they are better) so these are still an option if they fullfil the requirements.
| Manufacturer/Model | Length | Clamp | Weight | Grip | Price | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chinook Pro1 Alloy | 150 - 212 | Generic/OEM | 2.63kg | 29mm | £245 | Excellent length range |
| Chinook Pro 1 Alloy RDG | 150 - 210 | Generic/OEM | 2.85Kg | 27mm | £239 | |
| North Sails Silver Series (2015 - 2018) |
160 - 210 | Custom iFRONT 2.0 | 2.55kg | 28mm | <£200 | Not enough range to cover old 7m+ sails |
| Duotone Silver Series (2019) |
160 - 220 | Custom iFRONT 2.0 |
2.55kg | 27mm | £239 | Excellent clamp, 150g heavier than Platinum |
| Duotone Silver Series (2020) |
" | " | " | " | " | Horrible colours! |
| Neil Pryde XF | 160 - 220 | Custom Alu. | 2.90kg | 28mm | £249 | Good clamp but HEAVY! |
I'm pretty tempted just to buy a 2019 Duotone Silver Series as they have an excellent clamp, durable grip and the right range. Unfortunately the 2020 ones are only available in hideous colours and I can't currently find a 2019 one (pre-2018 only have 160-210 range which is not enough).
One thing that you quickly realise is that most sub-£500 booms are basically the same*. They have the same clamp and the carbon arms clearly come out of the same factory in China, although some claim different extension lengths. Bonus points to duotone by saying this in their brochure about their EPX boom ("we make exclusivity affordable for everyone because it is largely identical in construction to most top products from other brands"). Very honest and to be encouraged!
* See pics from surf-magazin.de review.
| Manufacturer/Model | Length | Clamp | Weight | Grip | Price | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Duotone EPX Carbon | 150 - 210 | Generic/OEM | 2.15kg | 25mm | £539 | Lightest |
| Duotone EPX Carbon | 160 - 220 | Generic/OEM | 2.45kg | 27.5mm | £559 | |
| GA Sails Slim Carbon Pro | 150 - 210 | Generic/OEM | 2.20kg | 25mm | €760 | |
| GA Sails Carbon Wave | 150 - 210 | Generic/OEM | 2.44kg | 29mm | £649 | |
| Goya Super Skinny | 150 - 200 | Generic/OEM | 2.20kg | 25mm | £699 | |
| MK CPX Carbon (Review) | 150 - 210 | Generic/OEM | 2.44kg | 27mm | £395 | Cheapest |
| Unifiber Carbon Monocoque | 140 - 200 | Generic/OEM | 2.24kg | 25mm | £449 | |
| Unifiber Carbon Monocoque Boom | 160 - 220 | Generic/OEM | 2.44Kg | 27mm | £499 |
Of these, only a couple offer the range that I need (Unifiber and duotone), both of which are coincidentally exactly the same weight as my existing aluminium Progression Comp. boom. On paper they tick most of the boxes, though I've read comments saying that the grip on the Unifiber is not very durable. Both use the same OEM clamp, so there's nothing to choose from there. RRP is basically the same, although last-year's Unifibers can be had on offer at the time of writing which makes them a little cheaper. If I didn't need the extra extension, the MK seems the best value.
Spare Parts: Pretty much zero chance for most of these "cheap" booms unfortunately.
This is possibly the best reason to buy a top-end alu. over a cheap carbon. Points to Unifiber though as they do seem to list some spares here.
Next up are the ones that I (mostly) can't afford - the custom-made ones (some are even made in the EU or US). Note that some still use Generic/OEM clamps, which doesn't really seem good enough at this price-point.
| Manufacturer/Model | Length | Clamp | Weight | Grip | Price | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aeron Carbon Slim Wave (Review) | 150 - 200 | Custom Alu. | 2.26Kg | 25mm | £699? | Alu.Clamp |
| Aeron Carbon Slalom/Race | 170 - 220 | Custom Alu. | 2.82kg | ? | 899€? | |
| Chinook Pro 1 Carbon | 150 - 210 | Generic/OEM | 2.15kg | 28mm | £689 | Light |
| Chinook Pro 1 Carbon | 160 - 226 | Generic/OEM | 2.30kg | 28mm | £730 | Large Range |
| AL360 E3 Carbon Slim | 150 - 200 | Custom | 2.19kg | 25mm | £849 | Shame no 160-220 option |
| AL360 E3 Carbon Wave/Slalom | 150 - 210 | Custom | 2.44kg | 28mm | £695 | Lurid gfx! |
| AL360 E3 Carbon Wave/Slalom | 160 - 220 | Custom | 2.51kg | 28mm | £605 | Made in EU |
| As above but personalised colour | " | " | " | " | +30€? | Not often advertised |
| Duotone Platinum (Review) | 160 - 220 | iFront 2.0 | 2.40kg | 28mm | £789 | Highly regarded |
| NeilPryde XC Carbon | ||||||
| Point-7 Carbon+ Pro | 150 - 200 | Custom | 2.40kg | 26mm | £599 | Made in EU |
| Streamlined Wave Carbon (SDM head) (Review) | 160 - 210 | Custom | ? | 27mm | £749 | |
| Severne Enigma Carbon V2 : Wave | 150 - 200 | Custom | 1.97kg | 25mm | £799 | So light! |
| Severne Enigma Carbon V2 : Slalom | 160 - 210 | Custom | 2.23kg | 27mm | £899 | Most expensive |
Again, only a couple of these actually offer the 160 - 220 range that I need. I'd probably buy a Duotone Platinum if I could afford it, as it ticks all of my boxes, but the AL360 is a pretty affordable option, if a tiny bit heavier than my existing smallest boom (but some of the colours are truly awful…).
If you follow this interesting forum thread you'll find results from surf magazin showing lots of booms that they measured for stiffness. Summary: The AL360, Duotone Platinum and Severne Enigma were stiffest by far (nothing else really came close).
Spare Parts: Quite impressive for most of these top-end booms, but not for all. Check carefully before buying!
See these links:
AL360 - also here, here and maybe here (sadly looks deceased in 2024)
Chinook
Duotone
24-7 Boardsports - a huge range of spares
wsurf.eu - carried a big range of spares, but website seems dead in 2024
easy-surfshop - mostly Unifiber parts
I bought an AL360 E3 Carbon 160-220 with a custom grip colour. After a couple of months use, this is what I think of it.
Good:
Bad:
UPDATE 1: After only 4 months both clips have now corroded and split, which is ridiculous. See picture below. Watch this space to see what AL360 have to say…

UPDATE 2: I never did get a reply. I bought some replacement clips from wsurf.eu (fantastic service by the way) as I needed them quickly, but they have only lasted a few months before starting to split in the same way. On further investigation the corrosion visible is not the cause of the split - it's purely the unsuitable plastic. I have raised a warranty claim to see what happens, but this does seem to be a rather obvious design flaw (the clips on my 20-year-old North booms are still perfect).
UPDATE 3: Communication via AL360's website doesn't seem to work! After my warranty claim was ignored too, I emailed them via info@al360.it and got a nice reply straight away (never trust technology!). They say their new clips have solved the corrosion problems and are sending some new ones out to me immediately, which is great news. These have now arrived and at least look slightly different, although the type of plastic still seems unsuitable to me. I've fitted one old-style clip and one new-style so that I can compare how they last. Watch this space…
UPDATE 4: It's now about a year since I wrote UPDATE3. The new-style clip sent by AL360 is still perfect, and the old-style one fitted at the same time has rusted and split in two. So, proof that AL360 have indeed fixed the problem :)
P.S. The back-end of my AL360 E3 Carbon has always been rubbish with its crappy plastic moulded cleat. I got fed up with it recently and wondered whether something better would fit. I had an old North Progression Comp boom-end lying around so I took off the back-end and removed the AL360 one too. Amazingly the old North part fits perfectly on the AL360 carbon tail-piece. The North back-end is made from the correct type of plastic, has a nice loop-loop-go system, and of course has a proper metal cleat. A great improvement and my AL360 boom is now much better. You can still buy the North part here - I'd highly recommend this mod.
UPDATE 5: I've had this boom long enough now that I've decided to trim it down to fit my sail quiver exactly. See my AL360 Boom Modification article.
E&OE - sorry for any mistakes that I may have made here, especially prices which were the best I could find as of August 2020.